Home    About    Contact Us     Contents    What You Can Do    Search

 Commentary

Home
Incorporation Not Inevitable
INCORPORATION Q&A
Services Will Decrease
Who Pays for Sewers

TAXES:

BUREAUCRACY:

CITY PROPONENTS:

WHAT YOU CAN DO:

OTHER CONSIDERATIONS:


TAXES:

*         Cities cost A LOT of money to operate . . . your money.

*             A thorough estimate has determined the average annual household increase in taxes to be at least $879 to live in the City of Sugar Creek Hills in order to maintain the current level of services that Jefferson County provides.

*         Businesses located within the City of Sugar Creek Hills will be required to impose Sugar Creek Hills sales tax, which is paid by you, the customer.  Due to the level of tax that will be required, businesses will be burdened that are trying to compete with businesses outside of the proposed city limits.  In the case of the businesses located within the Sugar Creek Hills boundary, they will be competing at a disadvantage with businesses just down the road should Sugar Creek Hills incorporate.  Customers will be inclined to shop elsewhere to purchase goods with a lower tax rate.

*         Utility bills (telephone, gas, electric, cable) for both residents and businesses will be subjected to Sugar Creek Hill’s utility tax rate, in addition to taxes already applied.  To see sample tax rates for an existing city, a portion of the Desoto City Services Guide has been provided on this site (it is the fourth image).

*         Vehicle sales tax paid at license office will increase when purchasing & licensing a vehicle (car, truck, motorcycle, boat, trailer, RV, etc.).  For a $30,000 vehicle, you pay $375 more at the license office with a 1.25% proposed Sugar Creek Hills sales tax.

*         Real estate and personal property tax would be imposed by the city due to lack of alternative sources.  This would be in addition to real estate and personal property tax collected by the county.

*         Upon incorporation, your current property tax liability WILL NOT BE REDUCED for county services that the county no longer provides.

*         Residential property within cities is usually given higher assessed property values, which means higher taxes.  This reflects the increased cost of building, doing business and day-to-day living in the city – not any added value that a city would provide.

*         In addition to federal and state income taxes, cities can impose an income or earnings tax on residents and workers.  Due to the lack of business-tax revenue for Sugar Creek Hills, this would be more likely to be imposed.  For example, since July 31, 1959, St. Louis residents and workers pay an earnings tax of one percent of their income to the city.  This is done in other cities throughout the midwest, not just in St. Louis, so be careful what you vote for.

*         City councils continually come up with new ways to generate tax revenue – don’t be fooled.

Top of Page


BUREAUCRACY:

*            Cities impose restrictions on activities:

o        Personal Fireworks Displays would require permits be obtained at a fee.

o        Burn ordinances restricting bonfires or the burning of yard debris/brush piles.

*           Cities create legislation, zoning ordinances and all manner of bureaucracy, which is a full-time job if trying to keep up with it.

*            Compliance with city zoning ordinances may require personal lifestyle changes, such as, cutting grass more frequently, parking restrictions, noise levels, etc.

*             Local zoning monitoring could result in fines for violation of ordinances.

*             To see sample bureaucratic ordinances, city permits, licenses, fees, etc, for an existing city, a portion of the Desoto City Services Guide has been provided on this site.

*             In addition to existing levels of government, cities use Eminent Domain, although they usually call it condemning property or else they impose fines until you comply.

*             Sugar Creek Hills police force would be required to issue petty fines/violations to fund the city without addressing real issues.

*             New licensing procedures (and fees) may become required annually for pet licensing and vehicle stickers.

*             Restrictions placed on the number of pets.

*             Bureaucracy is ongoing and never ending.  City councils never stop creating new restrictions, ordinances or levying taxes.

 Top of Page


CITY PROPONENTS:

*             The Sugar Creek Hills incorporation proposals would have to be approved by the voters.

*             Mr. Harding, the leader and spokesman of the Sugar Creek Hills Citizens for Incorporation, speaks of better control.  The control he refers to will affect your way of life.  Additionally, he would likely be appointed by the County as the first interim mayor until an election can be held.  However, if voters reject incorporation, then, of course, no city government will be needed.

*             Always question anyone who would ask you to vote for a city to provide better control . . . there are many hidden costs to incorporation!

Top of Page


WHAT YOU CAN DO:

*            You have the power to vote a city down -- go to the polls & VOTE NO.

*            Get the facts!  Don't believe uninformed claims that incorporation is inevitable.  Don't give up, get involved.

*         Unite to fight any attempt to incorporate!  Let’s join together and understand the facts.  Become involved and informed so that you can help educate other residents.  Share this information and contact us to volunteer.

*             If you moved to High Ridge and/or Jefferson County to get away from the city, then join us in fighting this city and all city proposals.

*             Petitions are legal documents.  Always read any documents before you sign them.  Do not trust what someone says regarding the contents.  It is much harder to remove your name from a petition than it is to sign it.

*             Analyze the financial COST of being a High Ridge citizen and determine whether there are any benefits that Sugar Creek Hills can provide that the county is currently not providing.  Please see Mr. Weber’s thorough study on the costs and benefits of living in a city.  As you will find, there are no benefits, only costs.

*         Before voting for any city, browse the web sites of other cities.  Look at their ordinances and all the councils that need to be supported with tax dollars and ask yourself . . . do I want this?

 Top of Page


OTHER CONSIDERATIONS:

*             Incorporation is absolutely NOT inevitable.  Much of St. Louis County is NOT incorporated.  Sappington & Afton are NOT incorporated.  Only 10% of the Fenton zip code is incorporated, 90% of Fenton is NOT incorporated.

*             The exhaustive 2-year study presented by Nelson Weber has proven that a city encompassing the entire 63049 zip code will not be financially feasible.  There is not enough business revenue to support it.  Where will the money come from?

*             City incorporation is not free.  Money (and lots of it) is required to keep a city functioning and providing services.  If a city becomes defunct, the county does not come to the rescue.  This means you continue to pay county taxes without receiving services.

*             Cities can be sued.  Liability insurance must be purchased immediately upon incorporation.  Legal counsel must be retained.  This represents a tremendous cost to the city.  (Arnold recently lost a $1 million lawsuit.)

*             The St. Louis area is crammed full of cities and municipalities already.  We all pay for the redundancy, inefficiency and lack of economies of scale in the provisioning of services.

*         The local TV news is filled with the squabbling and mismanagement of cities like Wildwood, Sunset Hills, Overland, Pagedale, et al.

*         City councils often legislate and vote for their own agendas without considering the best interest of the citizens.

*             You already have Federal, State, and County governments.  Do you seriously need a fourth layer?

*             Extra time and dollars will be required of you to comply with all of the annual bureaucratic licenses, stickers, etc.

*         Regardless of the incorporation proposal, all cities require increased taxation to exist.  All cities have the potential for waste, corruption, abuse of powers, cronyism, etc.  Who’s going to monitor what goes on? 

*         Many have argued that a city is needed for improvements to schools and the creation and maintenance of parks.  Counties are responsible for improvements to schools, and parks can be just as beautiful whether they are state or county maintained.  Cities do not offer anything more than what the county can offer.

*             Need further convincing?  Look at the city of Byrnes Mill, just southwest of High Ridge.

o        Their police force is regarded as a notorious ticketing machine that uses questionable tactics to extract large amounts of annually budgeted revenue from traffic fines.

State Representative Mike Frame held a Town Hall Meeting on June 28, 2007, to address the public on “Byrnes Mill Police Issues”. This meeting was precipitated due to the large number of complaints Representative Frame had received from the public about the Byrnes Mill police and its alleged abuse of authority.

o        They have forced sewers on its citizens – even those with properly working septic systems.  There is no testing . . . only compliance!  For those who objected, they were told in a public meeting that they would be taken to court if they did not hook up.  And, guess who pays for the sewers . . . not the city.  The homeowner is financially responsible for the hookup to the main line while their tax dollars pay for the rest!  NOTHING IS FREE!

Top of Page


Home ] Incorporation Not Inevitable ] INCORPORATION Q&A ] Services Will Decrease ] Who Pays for Sewers ]

Send mail to webmaster@highridgefacts.org with questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2007 High Ridge Facts
Last modified: 02/15/10